Blog

You have an idea.

You think it solves a real problem. Perhaps friends have told you it is brilliant. Maybe potential customers have said they would use it. You may even have conducted research showing that there is a market for what you want to offer.

But there is one question that eventually has to be answered:

Will somebody actually pay for it?

Until that happens, you don’t really know.

People can like your idea without buying it.

They can praise it without buying it.

They can complete your survey and tell you they would definitely use it without buying it.

Because there is a significant difference between someone saying:

“That’s a great idea.”

and saying:

“How do I pay?”

This is why one of the most important lessons I want new founders to understand is:

Compliments are not validation. Payment is evidence.

“Nobody Will Ever Pay You £3,000”

I learned this lesson through my own business.

Years ago, I worked with a colleague helping organisations raise grant funding.

At the time, we charged clients approximately £500 upfront and then received a percentage of the funding we helped them secure. Typically, we might help someone raise between £5,000 and £15,000.

After doing this for some time, I began thinking differently.

I wanted us to work on much larger funding opportunities. Instead of helping clients raise £5,000 or £10,000, I wanted to help organisations pursue funding of £100,000 or more.

But that would require a different service.

And I wanted to charge approximately £3,000 upfront, in addition to our success fee.

My colleague thought the idea was ridiculous.

She was convinced nobody would pay it.

Why would somebody who could pay us £500 suddenly pay £3,000?

We discussed it at length, but eventually it became clear that this wasn’t a direction she wanted to pursue. We parted amicably and remain friends to this day.

But I decided to test the idea.

The first few people I approached effectively confirmed everything she had said.

No.

£3,000 was too expensive.

They weren’t interested.

At that point, I could easily have concluded:

“She was right.”

But I kept testing.

With some clients, I initially helped them secure smaller amounts of funding. Once I had demonstrated what I could do, I went back and proposed moving to the next level.

Some eventually paid the £3,000 upfront.

Others agreed to pay in instalments.

The important thing was that people began buying.

The market had answered the question.

And the answer was yes.

We continued developing the offer, and in the first year the grant-funding business generated approximately £100,000 without major advertising.

Imagine if I had never tested it.

I could still have been charging £500 because somebody I respected had told me:

“Nobody will pay £3,000.”

The Market Gets the Final Vote

This is one of the things I have learned about business.

You can believe something will work.

Someone else can believe it won’t.

You can argue about it for hours.

Neither opinion settles the question.

The market does.

That doesn’t mean you blindly launch every idea you have. But once you have enough reason to believe that something solves a genuine problem, eventually you need to put it in front of potential customers and ask them to make a decision.

Not:

“Do you like this?”

But:

“Would you pay for this?”

Better still:

“Would you like to buy it?”

Because payment changes the conversation.

Why Compliments Aren’t Enough

People are generally kind.

If you tell a friend:

“I’ve been thinking about starting a business helping people with X,”

they may respond:

“That sounds brilliant!”

And they may genuinely mean it.

But that doesn’t tell you whether you have a business.

Someone can genuinely like your product and still not buy it.

Perhaps the problem isn’t important enough.

Perhaps your solution doesn’t solve it well enough.

Perhaps they don’t trust the solution yet.

Perhaps the price is wrong.

Or perhaps they were never really your customer.

The moment someone has to exchange money for what you are offering, they have to make a different decision.

They are no longer simply evaluating whether your idea sounds nice.

They are asking:

“Is solving this problem worth more to me than the money you are asking me to give you?”

That’s why payment is such powerful evidence.

Why Founders Avoid Asking for Money

There is another reason we delay this moment.

It is emotionally easier to work on the product.

You can build your website.

Improve the logo.

Write the business plan.

Develop another feature.

Conduct more research.

Create another presentation.

All of those activities allow you to remain busy without facing the most uncomfortable question:

Will somebody buy this?

Because once you ask someone to pay, they can say no.

And rejection doesn’t feel good.

It is very easy to interpret:

“I don’t want to buy this”

as:

“Your idea is rubbish.”

Or even worse:

“You’re rubbish.”

But that isn’t what the market has told you.

A no is information.

The question is:

What is the no telling me?

That is where some of your most important learning begins.

Your Marketing Starts Before Your Product Is Finished

One mistake founders make is thinking there are two separate stages:

First, create the product.

Then, market it.

I don’t believe it works that way.

Your marketing begins while you are creating the product, not after you have finished it.

The conversations you have with customers help you develop the product.

The questions they ask help you understand your messaging.

Their objections help you understand what needs changing.

Their willingness—or unwillingness—to pay helps you understand the value they place on the problem.

If you develop your entire product in isolation and only show it to customers once it is finished, you have denied yourself one of your most valuable sources of product-development information:

the customer.

Start With a Minimum Viable Product

You don’t need the perfect product before you begin selling.

You need something capable of solving a real problem.

This is the idea behind a Minimum Viable Product, or MVP.

It may solve one important problem rather than ten.

It may be relatively simple.

It may require considerable improvement later.

That’s okay.

Think about the phone in your pocket.

You bought a finished product.

Yet periodically, the manufacturer tells you:

An update is available.

Why?

Because “finished” doesn’t mean incapable of improvement.

Problems are discovered.

New capabilities become possible.

Better ways of doing things emerge.

Your first product can work in exactly the same way.

You create something capable of solving the customer’s problem.

You put it into the market.

You learn.

Then you improve it.

Your first version does not need to be your final version.

How Many Sales Prove That People Will Pay?

There isn’t one universal number.

It depends on the business.

If you sell a £10,000 service and two independent customers pay £10,000, that is significant evidence.

If you’re selling something for £20, two sales tell you much less. You may need 10, 20, 50 or more sales before you begin seeing a meaningful pattern.

If your business model depends on large numbers of users, registrations or traffic before monetisation, different metrics may matter during the early stages.

So don’t become obsessed with a magic number.

Ask:

What level of evidence would be meaningful for this particular business model?

And look at the context.

If you approached five well-qualified potential customers and three bought, that’s interesting.

If you approached 5,000 people and one bought, that’s telling you something very different.

Validation is not simply the number of sales.

It is what the pattern of behaviour is teaching you.

Start With People You Already Know

I generally encourage new founders to start close to home.

Who do you already know who genuinely experiences this problem?

Former colleagues?

Professional contacts?

Friends?

People within your community?

Existing clients?

The advantage is that you already have some relationship and credibility.

You may not need an elaborate website, sophisticated funnel or large advertising budget to begin.

Make the offer.

Deliver.

Learn.

Then ask satisfied customers:

“Who else do you know who has this problem?”

Your first customer can lead to your second.

Your second can lead to your third.

Gradually, your circle expands.

This is particularly powerful for experienced professionals because you may already have spent years building relationships within the market you eventually want to serve.

What If Nobody Buys?

This is where founders can draw the wrong conclusion.

You make your offer.

Nobody buys.

Therefore:

Bad business idea.

Maybe.

But not necessarily.

There are several possibilities.

You may have the wrong product.

But you could also have:

• the wrong customer;
• the wrong offer;
• the wrong price;
• the wrong message;
• the wrong sales approach;
• the wrong channel;
• or a solution that needs adapting.

You need to learn from the result before deciding what it means.

Bob Marley’s First Records Didn’t Take Off

There is a wonderful example of this in Bob Marley’s early journey.

In 1962, the teenage Marley recorded some of his first singles for producer Leslie Kong, including Judge Not. The recordings failed to connect with the public, and according to Bob Marley’s official history, he was paid just $20 for those early recordings. (bobmarley.com)

Imagine using that first result as the final verdict on Bob Marley.

The market could easily have appeared to be saying:

Nobody wants this.

But that wasn’t the end of the story.

Marley continued developing his music, working with others, changing, learning and finding audiences. His first commercial response wasn’t a verdict on his ultimate potential.

And that’s an important lesson for founders.

The result of your first test is information, not necessarily a final judgement.

Sometimes the correct response is to stop.

Sometimes it is to change the product.

Sometimes it is to change the customer.

Sometimes it is simply:

Learn, adapt and test again.

This Is Where the Founder Becomes a Builder

Within the Founder’s Journey, this moment represents an important transition.

During the Explorer Stage, you are trying to discover your Founder–Product–Market Fit.

Is this the right problem?

Is this the right product?

Is this the right market?

And importantly:

Are you the right founder to pursue it?

Then something happens.

Someone pays you.

You deliver.

They are satisfied.

Perhaps they recommend you.

Then another customer buys.

Now you have begun answering an important question:

Will people actually buy this?

This is where you begin moving into what I call the Builder Stage.

But notice what the first sale has not proved.

It hasn’t proved that you can make a living.

It hasn’t proved that you can generate customers consistently.

It hasn’t proved that you have a repeatable sales process.

It hasn’t proved that you have a scalable business.

It has simply provided your first significant piece of evidence:

Somebody will pay.

And that is a major milestone.

Your Seven-Day Test

If you have a business idea right now and don’t know whether people will pay for it, I want you to do something over the next seven days.

Don’t build the entire business.

Don’t spend seven days improving your logo.

Don’t disappear for six months developing the perfect product.

Identify one problem you can solve.

Create the simplest credible version of the solution you can deliver.

Then identify five people who genuinely experience that problem.

Talk to them.

Show them what you are proposing.

Ask what they think.

Ask what would make it more valuable.

Ask what they would be willing to pay.

And if the conversation indicates that your solution fits what they need, ask the question that founders sometimes avoid:

“Would you like to buy it?”

Then listen carefully to what happens next.

If they buy, you’ve learned something.

If they don’t, you’ve learned something.

Either way, you now know more than you did when the idea existed only inside your head.

Stop Looking for Certainty. Start Looking for Evidence.

You don’t need certainty before you start.

Business rarely gives you that.

What you need is evidence.

A compliment is encouraging.

A survey is useful.

A conversation can teach you something.

But eventually somebody has to make the transition from:

“I like it.”

to:

“I’ll buy it.”

That is when your idea begins encountering the real market.

And that is when you begin learning what your business might actually become.

Compliments are not validation. Payment is evidence.

Where Are You on the Founder’s Journey?

If you’re trying to determine whether you have found the right business, get your first paying customers, turn occasional sales into a sustainable income or build a business that can operate without depending entirely on you, the Founder’s Journey Assessment can help you identify your current stage.

Take the FREE Founder’s Journey Assessment to discover your stage and what you should focus on next.

Access the FREE FOUNDER’S JOURNEY ASSESSMENT TOOL HERE: https://forms.gle/tTwiiRcGc61WznW66.